Throw Out Your Stock Training Plan: The Top 4 Reasons You Need a Coach

There are so many running resources available online today: Runner’s World, Active, and Running Times among others. Each has training plans for beginner, intermediate, and advanced runners depending on the race. While it’s a good start and they have certainly motivated thousands to run, I wouldn’t recommend using one of these stock plans.

Legendary Coach Bill Bowerman with Steve Prefontaine.

Sure, they’re easy and free. Just go to one of the websites, choose your goal race and running level (however arbitrary levels like “intermediate” may be), and you have a 12-week program for that 5k coming up. But are these stock running programs the best choice for runners who care about their running and want to improve?

I say absolutely not. If you want to train seriously – as a new runner looking to run your first race, or a seasoned athlete who wants to run a personal record – then stock plans are not the best route for accomplishing your goals. For your best results you will want a more personalized approach to your training. A custom training plan from an online running coach or in-person coach will come with personalized benefits (like considering your injury history or schedule) and will help you not only run fast, but avoid injury and learn more about your training.

A lot of runners think they don’t need a coach. I’m one of them. But I also had several coaches throughout my 8 years of distance running in high school and college. I spend most of my free time talking about running, writing about running, or reading about running. I tend to think I know my stuff. Just as a web programmer wouldn’t hire another web programmer, I am not going to hire a coach.

But most people don’t have over a decade of experience being a runner, the majority of the time spent with a coach. Most people don’t read about running constantly. That’s where having a coach can be hugely beneficial. Training needs to be personalized so you know when to back off and when to train hard. You need to do all of the “little things” that help prevent injury.

The most common (and by far, the easiest) option for most people is getting an online coach who can develop a custom training plan for your goal race. You could also join a local running group or find a coach in your region who can work with you one-on-one, but these options tend to be either too logistically time-consuming or expensive.

A coach, whether in-person or online, can help you reach goals faster and safer than a stock plan or winging it by yourself. I’m personally in favor of runners getting a coach, and here’s why.

1)  Stock plans don’t consider your fitness baseline.  Your “fitness baseline” doesn’t necessarily have to do with running, but rather your overall level of athleticism at this point in time.  Even new runners can be completely different athletically – my main point of contention with these one-size-fits-all training plans.  The non-runner who plays basketball twice per week and lifts weights is in far better shape than the coach potato.  Both are new to running, but should they use the same training program?  No way!

2)  Stock plans lack customization. These programs don’t consider a person’s running history (besides the vague beginner, intermediate, and advanced distinctions), professional and family schedule, and injury history.  They also don’t offer personalized advice and workouts tailored to the strengths of a particular athlete.  These are huge perks and advantages that uncoached runners are doing without.

3)  Typical online running plans are only about running. To quote Jay Johnson, good runners need to be good athletes.  A custom program will include (if it’s any good, of course) lifting advice, general strength workouts, core exercises, and specific types of running that make you stronger, resistant to injury, and an overall better runner.  Take a look at any elite runner’s training and running only occupies half to a third of their total training!

4)  There’s no flexibility in stock programs.  It’s just a monthly calendar with each workout prescribed daily.  The workouts are set with no variation, and we all know variation is paramount to getting faster and avoiding injury.  Workouts and total running volume should be modified occasionally based on how your body feels, what’s going on in your personal or professional life, and the progression of your training.  Small variations include all of the “little things” that help you get stronger and avoid injury – the diet and recovery recommendations, the efficient form and biomechanics tips, and race-day suggestions to help you run your best.

These are my top 4 biggest complains about all those stock plans floating around the web.  It’s frustrating when new runners choose these cookie-cutter programs and after only 1-2 weeks have questions regarding a workout, the schedule, or running in general.  Where do they turn?  Most often, they go to the site’s message boards which are mostly filled with other new runners looking for answers.  It’s usually not the most helpful community when the majority are beginners.

The most common objection to getting a personal coach is price.  Online coaches can cost up to $150 per month and in-person coaches can cost that much per session.  There are certainly more reasonable options that still include the perks I outlined above (like Strength Running), but often it’s an additional burden to runners.

Usually this is a fair objection, but sometimes I’m blown away by what people are willing to spend on running gadgets and gear (what happened to minimalist running? People buy heart rate monitors, Garmin GPS systems, fancy 100 lap watches (my Timex cost $30 four years ago), the latest technology apparel, and $140 running shoes because they think they need to.  These new toys are not essential to being a good runner and will not make you faster.

If runners stopped buying non-essential toys that aren’t going to make them faster, and instead invested in a running coach, we would see faster runners at races across the country.  Nike and Garmin may see a decline in sales, but they’re not in the business of making you a better runner.  They’re in the business of outfitting you with expensive gear.

Consider what’s important and spend appropriately.  After all, a customized training program is the best tool you have for improving as a runner.  If you’re interested in working with me personally to help you achieve your running goals, email me or visit my coaching page.

How many of you avoid the high-tech gadgets and work with a running coach?  Do you think it was worth it?  Has anybody found the cookie-cutter online programs to be frustrating?

Was this post helpful?

Then you'll love the free email lessons I've never released here on the blog. Enter your email and you'll get:

  • The exact strength exercises that prevent injuries
  • Workouts that boost your speed (even for beginners)
  • Pacing strategies, coaching Q&A, and more

Comments

  1. The biggest complaint I have with stock training plans is the lack of flexibility. You may find yourself having a bad week or missing a week of training due to illness or injury and are left wondering what to do after. Should you pick up where you left off but then you are a week behind. Should you just skip that week? But you may not be ready for the next weeks workouts physically. The best solution is learning as an individual runner what works best for yourself and how to create your own adaptable plan and train yourself. However this takes years to learn therefore for beginners it is a great idea to seek out a coach who can be a valuable tool to you as a runner.

  2. andol charles says:

    hi my name is andol charles and i will need some help to improve my time my races are 8oom and 15oom

  3. I agree with all your points here, but these stock running plans have made running easier to slide into (for non-athletes). I tried the Couch to 5K and am now doing the One Hour Runner plan…I don’t have access to any coach or any kind of guidance, so I find these plans quite useful.

    • True, they can be helpful, but they’re cookie cutter plans in a world where no two people are the same. I have a philosophical problem with that, especially when custom programs can be designed for a fairly low price (see my coaching page, for example).

      • That’s great, but you’re actually not decreasing cost burden to the runner. You’re just shifting it from “Nike and Garmin” to the running coaches. I can’t afford to pay a running coach, so I use stock running plans and then tailor them to my own needs. Couch to 5K helped me get off the couch and enjoy running, but if someone had told me I needed to spend money on a running coach to get started I never would have.

  4. I’ve never found any value in those plans as they assume parameters that are the same for everyone. I’ve also always laughed over the years at the descriptions in most plans for mileage or background. I’ve read many books that read advanced 5k sub 17:00: runs 7 days a week, 50-70 mpw, etc. I could never look at those since I ran 15:41 for 5k and 1:13:50 for a half both on 30 mpw. If you line up my times I should use an advanced plan but if you go by mileage I barely hit intermediate. I am a high quality, low mileage runner and I’m sure there are people on the other end who run 50 plus more miles then the plans suggest. I agree about a good coach but they are hard to find.

    • Hey Bill, thanks for the comment! I know what you mean – we have similar times and I always am far out of the ranges described in these plans. Running is so personalized that stock plans almost always need to be changed for them to be of any benefit.

      Good coaching can be hard to find, but here are reputable coaches that I either personally know or trust: Greg McMillan (www.mcmillanrunning.com), Lowell Ladd (www.2lcoaching.com), and Bryon Powell (www.irunfar.com). And I also offer a few different coaching options depending on what you’re looking for.

Trackbacks

  1. […] running form is probably the most overlooked aspect of the sport.  Beginner runners sign up for cookie-cutter training plans that have tempos, long runs, and interval workouts but there’s no mention of the right way to […]

  2. […] Throw Out Your Stock Training Plan: The Top 4 Reasons You Need a Coach: This post over at Strength Running discusses why stock training plans that you will find online or in running books will not work for most people.  They are inflexible and don’t take your individual strengths and weaknesses into account.  I agree that a coach can be valuable to many runners or you should learn how to create your own training plans. […]

  3. […] and workouts for the next three months (just a rough outline – or else it would just be a cookie-cutter plan). Having a renewed outlook on your running and being reinvigorated to train are important for […]

  4. […] race is as much an art as it is a science. This is one of the reasons I’m not a fan of cookie-cutter training plans that aren’t based on your own personal history. Custom training plans just work […]

  5. […] noticed the approach. He commented, “Like many runners out there, I would grab a generic running plan and tweak it to meet my needs. But I felt as though the new plan was customized for me and my […]